Re: [Yaffs] Move yaffs source control to git?

Top Page
Attachments:
Message as email
+ (text/plain)
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Author: Ross Younger
Date:  
To: yaffs
Subject: Re: [Yaffs] Move yaffs source control to git?
Charles Manning wrote:
> We have been discussing moving from cvs to git in early 2010.


At my work we switched over from cvs to mercurial a couple of months ago.

The three leading DVCS contenders (hg, git and bzr) all do generally the
same job, with a few differences in the philosophical details. Once
you've climbed one learning curve you're pretty much there for all of
them, though git's is reputed to be a bit steeper. (Personally, I found
no real problems with git, making fairly heavy use of it on a personal
repo for several months, but I can see there is a difference.)

A concern for us was the level of Windows client support; we found that
git was a bit lacking in this regard.

Git seems to expose more low-level power features, which you may not
need; it also makes it easier to get really confused and/or shoot
yourself in the foot!

It's often straightforward to import your entire CVS history to a DVCS.
In fact I have a daily cron job which pull any new changes from the
yaffs2 CVS into my internal staging repo and emails me about them.
You'll be happy to hear that it runs without a hitch, though other
projects have had trouble with the conversion.

You might find our public repo for the eCos port of YAFFS interesting,
if nothing else by way of showing you what the YAFFS codebase looks like
in a mercurial repo (albeit viewed through the lens of the different
eCos directory layout). The graph view shows how my porting and merging
work relates: http://hg-pub.ecoscentric.com/yaffs-ecoscentric/graph/


Ross

-- 
eCosCentric Ltd, Barnwell House, Barnwell Drive, Cambridge CB5 8UU, UK
Registered in England no. 4422071.                 www.ecoscentric.com